I’m no stranger to playing the Tooth Fairy. Granted, the costume would fit me a little weird, but as to the actual act of replacing a tooth with two dollars without waking the kid up, I’m a pro. But there’s one finer point of playing the tooth Tooth Fairy that’s eluded me until now, and I finally want an answer:
What the hell am I supposed to be doing with all these teeth?
Currently, I have a baggie containing my 8-year-old’s upper right incisor stashed in a desk drawer. I’m telling myself it’s only there temporarily, but that implies I have some grander design for the tooth. I do not. Sloan, likewise, has informed me that the corresponding tooth on the left side is also really loose. By this time next week, I expect to have paid 4 dollars for used human body parts (maybe earlier if her school has another mandatory loose tooth extraction event, more commonly known as ‘Dodgeball’).
I really have no clue what is expected of me every time I come into possession of another one of her teeth. I’ve thrown away a few and felt absurdly guilty about it. “This is your little girl’s central incisor!” my inner monologue seems to shout at me, “Don’t you want to stash it away forever to remember this moment?! Don’t you want to spend 275 dollars on a gold trimmed keepsake box like some kind of medieval reliquary displaying the toenail of St. James?”

Seriously: $275. The same place also sells a 2 inch porcelain Noah’s Ark toy that costs as much as my first car.
But for all that guilt, do I really want to keep these things? Will I ever get out the pouch of loose teeth that I’ve kept like some kind of rag-and-bone man to coo adoringly over them? I can’t really see myself ever doing that. Maybe if it were the little stuffed Clifford doll that she took everywhere as a toddler I could; that’s a relic of early childhood with a lot of emotional history attached. I don’t feel that way about her second bicuspid.
Of course, the whole question of whether to keep the teeth is just one outgrowth of the fact that none of us parents seem to have any clue what we should or shouldn’t be keeping. Forget just teeth; anything that spends more than 5 minutes in the kid’s presence feels like there’s some pressure to keep in perpetuity.
Baby booties? You’re supposed to keep those, apparently. Baby blanket? Store that thing forever. Drawings and crafts?
Dear god, where do you even begin with the drawings and crafts…?
I have like 3 banker boxes worth of drawings sitting in my garage, plus smaller caches of rumpled, doodled-on paper scattered throughout the house. None of these drawings will ever get looked at again, but for some reason it seems important that I keep them. It might just be easier for me to pre-shred them and make mouse nests out of the remains myself.
It’s not just vague guilt keeping me from tossing this felled-redwood worth of paper into the trash, either. Kids also seem to have a sixth sense for the location of every doodle they’ve ever produced, and will guard this mountain of crumpled printer paper like some kind of dragon that just raided an Office Max.
At least the drawings can be stacked; it’s the crafts that I struggle most with. The crafts take up 50 times as much space, break any time they’re touched, and shed a trail of beads and sequins like a bedazzled golden retriever. Once the kid discovers those craft chests you might as well just accept that your entire house is going to look like a parade float just exploded and throwing away any spec of it will be met with resistance.

This kit contains roughly 2,000 pieces and is somehow capable of producing 3,000 things that you’ll be expected to store.
Now that my younger daughter is beginning to reach drawing age, I’m worried that it’s either time to make some major cuts to what I’m willing to store, or just accept that my new role in life is guardian of an ever growing stockpile of barely remembered keepsakes. I’ll definitely need another fridge to hang all her best artwork on, and possibly a second garage for the rest.
…Anyway, my kid just walked past chewing gum, so I probably need to go hit an ATM before the end of the day. All these teeth aren’t gonna pay for themselves.
Feel free to buy me a cup of coffee at paypal.me/inessentialreading if you enjoyed the column



